Against Nostalgia?
Brad Gregory on the Divisive Character of the Reformation
Aug 29, 2013
Pro Ecclesia Vol. XXII, No.4

Against Nostalgia? Brad Gregory on the Divisive Character of the Reformation
236KB ∙ PDF file
According to Gregory, modernity's probiems—and in particular its ^^r^uralism —should be traced to the Reformation. As he puts it in foe introduction to his m^isterial book, The Unintended Reformation, his principal argument is "that foe Western world today is an e^raordinarily complex, tangled product of rejections, retentions, and transformations of medieval Western Christianity, in which foe Reformation era consti- tutes foe critical watershed" (2). In Gregory's genealogical account of modernity, it is the Reformation, and in particular its sola scriptura claim, that made it impossible to secure a unified, institutional life and that ulti- mately led to foe individualism of modernity with its lack of resources to shore up even the most basic common moral, political, and legal claims. No doubt-and not entirely unsurprisingly considering his genealogy of failures-Gregory will be accused of nostalgically looking back to foe institutionalized worldview of medieval sacramentalism.
Download